Do you have collateral? If the answer is no, then your only option is an unsecured consolidation loan. If the answer is yes, then think about whether or not you want to tie your home to this type of loan.
How much debt do you owe? Add up all of the debts you want to consolidate. If the amount equals more than $10,000, then you’ll probably need to choose a secured consolidation loan. For lower debt amounts, you can choose either type of loan.
What are the interest rates on your debt? Remember that an unsecured loan is going to involve higher interest rates than a secured one. If those rates are going to be close to what you are paying on the debt you want to consolidate, then you may want to go with a secured consolidation loan instead.
Do you need lower payments? If the purpose of consolidation is to make your debt payments more manageable, you may not want to choose an unsecured loan. Because the terms of these loans are usually shorter, you may end up paying significant monthly payments. If you just want to eliminate some high interest debt or make managing your debt easier, then either type will work well for your needs.